Home » Nelson Havi names Lady Justice Christine Meoli among judiciary weakest links over delayed justice
Editor's Picks

Nelson Havi names Lady Justice Christine Meoli among judiciary weakest links over delayed justice

Senior Counsel Nelson Havi has publicly exposed Lady Justice Christine Meoli’s weak performance record, ranking her a D+ judge after comparing her output with two of the High Court’s strongest performers.

Havi released figures showing Justice Meoli delivered only 45 judgments, 27 final rulings and 30 interlocutory rulings.

In the same period, Lady Justice Teresa Odera produced 109 judgments, 324 final rulings and 166 interlocutory rulings, while Lady Justice Teresia Matheka delivered 157 judgments, 87 final rulings and 108 interlocutory rulings.

Havi stated bluntly that Meoli scored below 50 percent and is unable to perform her duties as a judge.

The numbers hit harder because Meoli is senior to both Odera and Matheka. She served long years as a magistrate, worked as Registrar of the High Court, and was appointed to the bench earlier than the two higher-output judges.

Havi reminded the public that she was the one who administered the oath to former President Mwai Kibaki during the controversial night-time ceremony.

The exposure followed a tense virtual court session in which Havi challenged Meoli over a ruling date set for 27 June 2027 nearly eight months away on a simple, uncontested review application.

When Havi insisted that the Civil Procedure Rules require rulings within 30 days, Meoli lost her cool, accused him of bullying judges, and demanded an apology after he called her moody. Havi refused, telling her that judges who cannot work should leave the Judiciary.

Havi later described Meoli as moody, impulsive, arrogant, lethargic and lazy. He wrote to Chief Justice Martha Koome demanding that the ruling be delivered within 30 days and asking the Chief Justice to examine Meoli’s fitness to continue. He also copied the Law Society of Kenya president, arguing that other advocates and litigants at the Kajiado High Court are suffering under the same delays.

Havi has made it clear: seniority is not performance. One judge delivers 45 judgments while another delivers 157.

He insists that underperforming judges like Meoli must either deliver justice on time or step aside.