Peter Gachuhi of Kaplan & Stratton has been drawn into a bitter legal dispute surrounding the estate of Kenya’s second Attorney General, the late Dr James Boro Karugu, involving a contested Will, a disputed Settlement Trust Deed and investigations into the authenticity of documents linked to the inheritance battle.
The controversy has also raised concerns about alleged witness interference, disputed company share transfers and the conduct of police officers involved in the investigations.
The dispute surrounding Karugu’s estate has become one of several contentious legal battles in Kenya involving inheritance, corporate ownership and questions about the authenticity of documents presented in court. Such disputes have left families and other interested parties entangled in prolonged proceedings as they seek clarity over property, business interests and the intentions of deceased relatives.
Karugu’s legacy in public service, law and business has been overshadowed by the succession battle, which centres on a purported Will and Settlement Trust Deed whose authenticity has attracted the attention of investigators.Investigations conducted by the Directorate of Criminal Investigations have raised serious questions about the documents, with the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions reportedly approving proposed criminal charges.
Gachuhi’s association with the contested testamentary documents and the administration of the estate has placed him at the centre of the legal controversy.
However, he has since filed constitutional proceedings challenging his intended prosecution, temporarily complicating efforts to move the matter forward.
The constitutional proceedings have added another layer to the dispute, with the substantive questions surrounding the documents still awaiting determination through the appropriate legal processes.
The case has also raised questions about how succession disputes involving valuable estates can continue through multiple legal proceedings before the central issues are conclusively resolved.
Tob Cohen Estate Dispute Raises Similar Questions Over Document Authenticity
The controversy surrounding Karugu’s estate is not an isolated case, with the inheritance dispute involving Dutch businessman Tob Cohen having also attracted attention over the authenticity of documents attributed to a deceased person.
During the murder proceedings involving Cohen, forensic testimony presented in court raised questions about signatures appearing on documents attributed to him, including his disputed Will.
The controversy surrounding Sarah Wairimu Cohen’s case brought the authenticity of documents connected to the estate into focus, particularly given the importance of such records in determining inheritance rights and the distribution of property.Whether any of the documents were forged remains a matter for the courts to determine.
The two disputes illustrate the legal complications that can arise when documents purporting to express the wishes of deceased individuals become contested by interested parties.
Wills and settlement agreements can have significant consequences for beneficiaries, particularly where substantial estates and valuable business interests are involved. When their authenticity is questioned, the resulting disputes can extend into criminal investigations and constitutional proceedings.
Three Accused Face Charges Over Alleged Fraudulent Share Transfer
Beyond the dispute surrounding the purported Will and Settlement Trust Deed, the Karugu estate controversy has extended into a separate criminal case involving Jane Wangechi Kabiu of Optimum Registrar’s, Eric Mwaura Karugu and Benjamin Githara Karugu.In Republic v Eric Mwaura Karugu, Jane Wangechi Kabiu and Benjamin Githara Karugu, Criminal Case No. E644 of 2025, the accused face charges connected to the alleged fraudulent transfer of a share belonging to Victoria Nyambura Karugu.
The disputed share was allegedly transferred from Mathara Holdings Limited to Centurion Holdings Limited, bringing questions of corporate ownership and the handling of company records into the proceedings.
The charges include conspiracy to defraud, forgery, uttering a false document and giving false information to a public officer, with different counts applying to the respective accused.
The case has introduced another dimension to the wider family dispute, with the contested share transfer forming the basis of criminal proceedings separate from the questions surrounding the purported Will and Settlement Trust Deed.
The accused subsequently approached the court seeking a reduction of their cash bail from KES 700,000 each to KES 20,000. Alternatively, they asked to be released on personal bond.
Their argument included the claim that the disputed share had a nominal value of only KES 100.
However, the application was dismissed on 21 October 2026 by Principal Magistrate Hon. Carolyne Nyaguthii Mugo, who maintained the existing cash bail requirements and accompanying conditions.
Magistrate Rejects Application to Reduce KES 700,000 Cash Bail
In considering the application, the magistrate addressed the constitutional presumption of innocence and the requirement that bail conditions remain reasonable.
The applicants sought a substantial reduction in the amount they were required to deposit, relying partly on the nominal value of the disputed share.
However, the court found that they had not presented sufficient grounds to justify the reduction they were seeking.
The ruling maintained the existing cash bail requirements, meaning the accused remained subject to the conditions previously imposed by the court.
The decision came amid prosecution concerns about the circumstances surrounding the case, including alleged interference with a potential witness and questions about compliance with court proceedings.
The bail application therefore brought several issues before the court beyond the financial value of the disputed company share.
While the accused are entitled to the presumption of innocence, the court was required to consider whether the grounds presented justified changing the existing bail arrangements.
Prosecution Raises Concerns Over Potential Witness Interference
One of the more serious issues raised by the prosecution involved Brenda Wanjiru Irungu, a former employee of Mathara Holdings Limited who was identified as a potential witness in the criminal proceedings.
The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions raised concerns about alleged interference with the former employee, referring to disputed Board resolutions allegedly connected to attempts to influence her.
The concerns have placed witness protection at the centre of the proceedings, particularly given the importance of independent testimony in cases involving disputed company records and alleged fraudulent transactions.
The prosecution also raised concerns about the accused persons’ alleged failure to attend scheduled court proceedings despite having given assurances that they would comply with their bail conditions.
Such concerns are significant in criminal proceedings because the ability of witnesses to provide evidence without intimidation or interference is central to the administration of justice.
However, the claims remain matters to be addressed through the relevant legal processes and should not be treated as established findings of guilt.
Police Conduct Also Comes Under Question
The dispute has also brought the conduct of police officers involved in the investigations into focus.
A complaint against OCS John Marubu of Kanunga Police Station was investigated by the National Police Service Internal Affairs Unit.In a letter dated 16 July 2026, the Internal Affairs Unit confirmed that the Inspector General had concurred with its recommendations and directed disciplinary action against the officer.
The development introduced another concern into the proceedings, particularly regarding the responsibility of police officers to handle investigations professionally and independently.Police officers play a critical role in gathering evidence, recording statements and ensuring that complaints are handled in accordance with the law.
Where complaints are raised against officers involved in sensitive investigations, the ability of oversight institutions to examine their conduct becomes particularly important.
The Internal Affairs Unit’s communication confirmed that recommendations had been made and that the Inspector General had directed disciplinary action.
Allegations Involving Benjamin Githara Karugu Add to Concerns
Further concerns were raised over an incident involving Benjamin Githara Karugu at Kiamara Estate.
He was accused of attempting on three consecutive occasions, and in the presence of three witnesses, to seize the firearm belonging to the complainant’s security officer during a confrontation.
The incident was reportedly reported to the police.
The claims have raised questions about the safety of complainants, witnesses and other individuals involved in the ongoing criminal proceedings.
Any established attempt to intimidate a witness, threaten a complainant or interfere with an investigation would undermine the administration of justice and compromise the ability of investigators to establish the facts.
The allegations therefore add to the concerns surrounding the wider dispute, which has already involved contested inheritance documents, company share transfers and questions about the conduct of individuals involved in the investigations.
They also underline the importance of ensuring that people participating in legal proceedings can do so without fear of intimidation.
Prolonged Legal Battles Leave Questions Over Estates and Ownership
The developments surrounding the Karugu estate illustrate the difficulties that arise when succession disputes intersect with corporate interests and criminal proceedings.
Disputed wills and settlement agreements can determine how estates are administered and who benefits from inherited property. Similarly, contested share transfers can affect ownership rights and control of business interests.
When the authenticity of such documents is challenged, the consequences can extend beyond the immediate parties, leaving families and other interested individuals waiting for years for clarity.
The situation becomes even more complicated when criminal investigations introduce questions about forgery, alleged fraudulent transactions, witness interference and police conduct.
These matters require careful examination because the outcome of the proceedings could have significant consequences for the people involved and the ownership interests being contested.
The courts must establish whether the documents in question are authentic, whether the alleged offences were committed and whether the individuals facing criminal proceedings bear any responsibility.











Add Comment