The reported ambition of Peter Mbuthia Gachuhi, a partner at Kaplan & Stratton Advocates, to attain the rank of Senior Counsel has drawn fresh attention to an unresolved dispute over the estate of James Boro Karugu, Kenya’s former Attorney General, and his wife Margaret Waithera Karugu.
Four years after James Karugu’s death on 10 November 2022, questions about the authenticity of documents presented as his Last Will and Testament, the administration of the estate, and related criminal investigations continue to linger.
The disputed documents and early proceedings
Barely three weeks after Karugu’s death, a meeting was held on 29 November 2022 at Elysian Resort along Kiambu Road.
Jane Wangechi Kabiu of Optimum Registrars reportedly introduced documents said to be the deceased’s Will and Settlement Trust Deed. Gachuhi attended and is said to have taken custody of the original Will, which named him as an executor and trustee.
The documents later faced challenges. Objectors pointed to grammatical errors, spelling mistakes, formatting issues and questions about how they were executed. Victoria Nyambura Karugu, the late Attorney General’s daughter, formally objected to the Will’s authenticity and the authority of the purported executors.
In July 2023, after Directorate of Criminal Investigations officers visited Kaplan & Stratton, Gachuhi and two other purported executors filed for probate in Succession Cause E916 of 2023.
Victoria filed her objection the following month. Investigators later reported difficulties obtaining the original documents for forensic examination, raising questions about custody and production of the instruments whose authenticity was under scrutiny.
Interventions and financial correspondence
In October 2023, Deputy Registrar Catherine Ng’ang’a reportedly wrote to the DCI suggesting that the forgery investigation should await the outcome of the succession objection. Gachuhi was copied into the correspondence while the objector was not. Concerns were also raised about an alleged ex parte meeting involving Gachuhi and the Deputy Registrar.
The episode prompted debate over whether criminal investigations into possible forgery should be deferred simply because related probate proceedings are pending.
Further questions arose in January 2026 when Gachuhi and Eric Mwaura Karugu, writing on Kaplan & Stratton letterhead, instructed Maramba Holdings Limited, a tea factory linked to the late James Karugu, to continue paying dividends into the deceased’s bank account pending further instructions from the purported executors. Certified extracts of the disputed Will were supplied to support the request. Senior Counsel Philip Murgor challenged the move, noting that the Will remained contested, no Grant of Probate had been issued and criminal investigations were ongoing.
ODPP-approved charges and constitutional challenge
In December 2025 the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions approved criminal charges against several individuals, reportedly including Gachuhi, relating to the disputed documents.
The proposed offences included forgery-related counts, uttering a false document and conspiracy to defraud. An approval to prosecute is not a conviction, and the presumption of innocence remains.
Gachuhi and others responded with Constitutional Petition E027 of 2026, seeking to stop the intended prosecution. The Attorney General opposed the petition.
In September 2026 Justice Gregory Mutai dismissed Victoria Karugu’s application to join those proceedings.
The ruling addressed procedure only and did not determine the authenticity of the Will or any criminal liability.
Senior Counsel and professional standards
Under Section 17 of the Advocates Act, Senior Counsel status is reserved for advocates who demonstrate irreproachable professional conduct and exemplary service. It is not awarded solely on the basis of years in practice or firm seniority.
The pending allegations and unresolved questions about the handling of disputed testamentary documents have therefore prompted discussion about whether such concerns should form part of any suitability assessment by the Committee on Senior Counsel.
Supporters of a careful review argue that the honour must rest on a process that maintains public confidence.
At the same time, they note that no criminal finding has been made against Gachuhi and that professional evaluation must respect both the presumption of innocence and the need for thorough examination of documented concerns.
The Karugu legacy
James Karugu rose to become Attorney General after education at Mang’u High School, Bowling Green State University and Lincoln’s Inn. Margaret Waithera Karugu was a pioneering senior civil servant. Both benefited from the Kennedy Student Airlift.
Their legacy includes the Dr James and Margaret Karugu Scholarship at Bowling Green State University, which supports African students.
The estate dispute has prolonged what many expected would be a more straightforward administration of the affairs of two distinguished public servants.
Transparency in the remaining legal processes, both criminal and succession, remains central to clarifying the late couple’s final intentions and protecting the integrity of their public record.











Add Comment